The Second Summer of the Sisterhood
by Ann Brashares
The pants are back for a second summer as Carmen, Tibby, Bridget, and Lena face new challenges, deeper heartbreak, and the continued magic of their unbreakable friendship.
Spoiler Warning
This review may contain spoilers. Read at your own discretion if you haven't finished the book yet.
Overview
The Second Summer of the Sisterhood takes Carmen, Tibby, Bridget, and Lena through another transformative summer. The pants continue their magic journey, but the girls face deeper challenges and more complex emotional territory than before.
What Makes This Sequel Special
Many second books disappoint, but Brashares delivers a sequel that matches and sometimes exceeds the original. The characters have grown, the stakes are higher, and the emotional depth is richer.
This Summer's Stories
Carmen
Dealing with her mother's new boyfriend and feeling increasingly disconnected from her father's growing family. She's struggling to find where she belongs when both households seem complete without her.
Key Theme: Finding your place when you feel like an outsider everywhere.
Tibby
Making an indie film and facing a pregnancy scare that forces her to confront her relationship and her future.
Key Theme: Taking responsibility for your choices and their consequences.
Bridget
At an archaeological dig in Turkey, physically running across continents but unable to outrun her grief and depression.
Key Theme: You can't escape pain by avoiding it - you have to face it to heal.
Lena
At drawing school, confronting her feelings for Kostos while learning her grandmother's heartbreaking love story.
Key Theme: Love is worth the risk, even when it's complicated and scary.
What I Loved
The Realistic Growth
The girls aren't magically better or wiser. They make mistakes, backslide, and struggle - just like real people growing up.
The Deeper Complexity
The issues are more nuanced:
- Carmen's family struggles don't have easy solutions
- Tibby's pregnancy scare is handled maturely
- Bridget's depression is explicitly addressed
- Lena's love story is beautiful and complicated
The Honest Portrayal of Love
First loves are messy. The book shows the joy, the pain, the confusion, and the growth that comes from opening your heart.
The Friendship Evolution
The girls' support for each other deepens. They learn when to offer comfort and when to offer truth.
Bridget's Arc
Her storyline is particularly powerful - showing depression, the inability to outrun grief, and the beginning of healing.
Key Themes
Growing Up Is Messy
There's no straight line from teenager to adult. Growth includes mistakes, setbacks, and learning the same lessons multiple times.
Grief Doesn't Follow a Timeline
Bridget's journey shows that healing isn't linear. Sometimes you think you're fine, then you're not. That's normal.
Love Requires Courage
Lena's arc shows that protecting your heart means missing out on beautiful, if complicated, love.
Family Is Complicated
Carmen's struggles remind us that family dynamics are complex, especially when families blend and change.
True Friends Tell the Truth
Friendship isn't just support - it's honesty, even when it's hard to hear.
The Emotional Depth
This book made me:
- Cry (multiple times)
- Laugh
- Remember my own confusing summers
- Text my best friends
- Think deeply about grief and healing
Standout Moments
Tibby's pregnancy scare: Handled with maturity and realism
Bridget's breakdown: Raw, honest, and necessary
Lena's art and love: Beautiful intersection of passion and fear
Carmen's explosion: Finally voicing her pain
Why 4.2 Stars?
This is an excellent sequel that deepens everything that made the first book special. The writing is strong, the characters grow convincingly, and the emotional resonance is powerful.
It's not perfect - some plot points are predictable, and occasionally the prose gets a bit heavy-handed. But these are minor issues in an otherwise excellent book.
Who Should Read This
- Anyone who loved the first book
- Readers navigating complex family situations
- Those dealing with grief or depression
- Anyone in a complicated love situation
- Young adults figuring out who they're becoming
- Anyone who needs their sisterhood
Comparison to Book One
What's Better
- Deeper emotional complexity
- More mature themes
- Richer character development
- More realistic consequences
What's the Same
- The magic of the pants
- The power of friendship
- Beautiful writing
- Authentic voices
Final Thoughts
The Second Summer of the Sisterhood proves that Ann Brashares understands her characters and her readers. She doesn't take the easy path or give simple answers.
The girls are messier, the situations are more complex, and the emotional stakes are higher - which makes it all more real and more resonant.
This is a book about:
- Facing what you've been running from
- Taking responsibility for your choices
- Opening your heart despite the risk
- Finding your voice and your place
- Holding onto your people through everything
Whether you're 15 or 50, this book reminds you that growth is hard, love is complicated, friendship is essential, and it's all worth it.
A beautiful, honest, emotionally rich sequel that honors its characters and its readers. ⭐⭐⭐⭐
My Notes & Takeaways
Growing Deeper
The Second Summer of the Sisterhood proves that sequels can equal or surpass originals. The girls are a year older, facing more complex challenges with deeper emotional stakes.
This Summer's Journeys
Carmen: At home with her mother's new relationship and struggling with her father's growing family, feeling increasingly like an outsider in both households.
Tibby: Making an indie film and dealing with complicated feelings when she discovers she might be pregnant.
Bridget: At an archaeological dig in Turkey, still running from grief and confronting what she's been avoiding.
Lena: At drawing school in Rhode Island, navigating her feelings for Kostos and learning about her grandmother's heartbreaking past.
The Growth
What makes this book special is how it shows realistic, messy growth:
- The girls make mistakes (sometimes the same ones twice)
- Relationships get more complicated, not simpler
- Family issues don't resolve neatly
- Love is wonderful and terrifying
- Supporting friends means honesty, not just comfort
Deeper Issues
Pregnancy scare and sexual responsibility
Grief and mental health (Bridget's depression is more explicitly addressed)
First love and heartbreak (Lena and Kostos's complicated situation)
Blended family struggles (Carmen's continued difficulty finding her place)
Identity and purpose (Each girl questioning who she wants to be)
What Resonates
Sophomore year of life - that awkward space where you're not new at this anymore, but you're still figuring it out.
Relationships evolve - first loves complicate, family dynamics shift, friendships deepen.
You can't outrun grief - Bridget's arc shows that avoiding pain doesn't make it disappear.
Love is complicated - Lena and Kostos show that loving someone doesn't mean it's simple or easy.
Why It Works
Brashares doesn't take the easy path. Characters make realistic mistakes, face real consequences, and grow in fits and starts - just like real people.
The pants are still magic, but the real enchantment is watching these four navigate increasingly complex waters while holding onto each other.
You Might Also Like
The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants
by Ann Brashares
Four best friends, one pair of magical jeans, and a summer apart that brings them closer together. A heartwarming story about friendship, growth, and the bonds that hold us together.
Girls in Pants: The Third Summer of the Sisterhood
by Ann Brashares
The summer before college - the last summer of innocence, of being together, of the magic pants. Carmen, Tibby, Bridget, and Lena face their biggest transition yet.
Forever in Blue: The Fourth Summer of the Sisterhood
by Ann Brashares
The summer after freshman year of college - the friends are scattered, changed, and struggling. The pants bring them together as they navigate who they're becoming.