Sisterhood Everlasting
by Ann Brashares
Ten years after college, the Sisterhood reunites in Greece for what should be a joyful reunion. Then tragedy strikes, changing everything forever.
Spoiler Warning
This review may contain spoilers. Read at your own discretion if you haven't finished the book yet.
Overview
Sisterhood Everlasting brings back Carmen, Tibby, Bridget, and Lena ten years after college. Tibby invites them to Greece for a reunion - then drowns, leaving the other three to navigate grief, guilt, and life without her.
What Makes This Book Challenging
This is not the Sisterhood book fans expected. It's darker, more painful, and fundamentally different in tone from the YA series. Tibby's death is devastating and divisive.
The Story
The Invitation
Tibby, mysteriously absent from their lives, sends tickets to Greece. Carmen, Bridget, and Lena go, expecting to reconnect with their missing friend.
The Tragedy
Tibby drowns. The circumstances are ambiguous - accident, suicide, or something else? They'll never know for certain.
The Grief
Each friend processes differently:
- Carmen: Throws herself into work, afraid to feel
- Bridget: Runs to Australia to find answers in Tibby's secrets
- Lena: Shuts down, unable to process the loss
They must find a way to grieve together while drowning separately.
What Works
The Honest Portrayal of Grief
The book doesn't sugarcoat. Grief is messy, angry, confusing, and isolating. Each character's response feels authentic.
The Adult Struggles
The book shows how life in your thirties doesn't always match your dreams:
- Carmen is successful but unfulfilled
- Bridget is married but restless
- Lena is stuck in the past
The Writing
Brashares' prose is more mature, more literary. The descriptions of grief are powerful and raw.
The Message
Life goes on after loss. You carry the person with you, but you must find a way forward.
What's Challenging
Tibby's Death
Many readers feel betrayed by this choice. Tibby was beloved, and her death feels cruel.
The Ambiguity
We never know if it was accident or suicide. Some readers find this realistic; others find it unsatisfying.
The Tone Shift
This is adult fiction, not YA. The shift is jarring for readers expecting the warmth of earlier books.
The Relentless Sadness
The book is heavy. There's little lightness or joy.
Why 3.2 Stars?
This is a well-written, honest exploration of grief and adult friendship. Brashares handles difficult material with skill.
However, the tonal shift is jarring, Tibby's death feels like a betrayal to many fans, and the relentless sadness can be overwhelming. It's a good book, but a divisive conclusion to a beloved series.
The Controversy
Team "It's Brilliant": This is real life. People die. Grief is important. The book is brave and honest.
Team "It's Betrayal": This isn't what we wanted from the Sisterhood. Tibby deserved better. The darkness doesn't fit the series.
Both perspectives are valid.
Who Should Read This
- Readers dealing with grief
- Those who want an honest portrayal of loss
- Fans of the series who want closure (even painful closure)
- Adult readers ready for a darker tone
- People navigating friendship in adulthood
Who Should Skip This
- Readers who can't handle beloved character death
- Those wanting the lightness of the original series
- Anyone looking for a happy ending
- Readers not in a place to handle heavy grief
Final Thoughts
Sisterhood Everlasting is a brave, painful, honest book about grief, guilt, and finding a way forward after devastating loss.
Is it what fans wanted? Probably not. Is it well-written and emotionally true? Yes.
Tibby's death is shocking and heartbreaking. The grief is relentless. The questions are unresolved. And that's real - sometimes life doesn't give us the ending we want.
This book is about:
- Surviving after losing someone irreplaceable
- Adult friendships after tragedy
- Living when you feel frozen by grief
- Carrying someone with you while moving forward
It's not an easy read, and it's not for everyone. But it's honest about one of life's hardest truths: we don't get to keep everyone forever, but the love remains.
A divisive but powerful conclusion that some will hate and others will find cathartic. ⭐⭐⭐
My Notes & Takeaways
A Heartbreaking Return
Sisterhood Everlasting reunites the four friends ten years after college - but this isn't the joyful reunion readers might expect.
Where They Are
Carmen: Married to Jones, successful actress, but feeling empty and disconnected.
Tibby: Missing - she's sent tickets to Greece but isn't answering calls.
Bridget: Teaching in San Francisco, married to Eric, struggling with what she wants from life.
Lena: In Rhode Island, teaching art, still single, still stuck.
The Tragedy
Tibby drowns in Greece. Whether it's accident or suicide is unclear, but she's gone. The three remaining friends must grieve, rage, and somehow find a way forward without her.
The Aftermath
Each friend processes grief differently:
- Carmen throws herself into work
- Bridget runs away to find Tibby's secrets
- Lena shuts down completely
They must learn to support each other while drowning in their own pain.
Why It's Difficult
The shift in tone: This is much darker than the YA books
Tibby's death: Devastating and polarizing for fans
The grief: Relentless and sometimes overwhelming
Unresolved questions: We never know for certain if it was accident or suicide
Why It Matters
The book honestly portrays:
- Grief in your thirties
- How loss changes friendships
- The struggle of adulthood when life doesn't match expectations
- How we carry on after losing someone irreplaceable
The Controversy
Many fans hate this book because it kills Tibby. Others find it a powerful, if painful, exploration of grief and friendship.
It's a divisive ending to a beloved series.
You Might Also Like
Forever in Blue: The Fourth Summer of the Sisterhood
by Ann Brashares
The summer after freshman year of college - the friends are scattered, changed, and struggling. The pants bring them together as they navigate who they're becoming.
Girls in Pants: The Third Summer of the Sisterhood
by Ann Brashares
The summer before college - the last summer of innocence, of being together, of the magic pants. Carmen, Tibby, Bridget, and Lena face their biggest transition yet.
The Second Summer of the Sisterhood
by Ann Brashares
The pants are back for a second summer as Carmen, Tibby, Bridget, and Lena face new challenges, deeper heartbreak, and the continued magic of their unbreakable friendship.