A Gate at the Stairs
by Lorrie Moore
A coming-of-age story set in the Midwest after 9/11. Tassie Keltjin takes a job as a nanny and finds herself drawn into a complex family dynamic that challenges her understanding of race, identity, and belonging.
Spoiler Warning
This review may contain spoilers. Read at your own discretion if you haven't finished the book yet.
Overview
A Gate at the Stairs is Lorrie Moore's first novel in over a decade, a literary coming-of-age story set in post-9/11 America. It follows Tassie Keltjin, a college student who becomes a nanny and witnesses the unraveling of a seemingly perfect progressive family.
What Makes This Book Notable
Moore is known for her short stories, and this novel showcases her gift for precise, insightful prose. Her observations about human nature, American culture, and the complexities of race and adoption are sharp and unflinching.
The Story
Tassie's World
Tassie is a college student from rural Wisconsin who takes a job as a nanny in Madison. She's observant, intelligent, and naive - the perfect lens through which to examine the contradictions of liberal America.
The Adoption
Her employers, Sarah and Edward, are adopting a biracial child. Tassie is drawn into:
- The awkward adoption meetings
- The performative discussions about race
- The commodification of the adoption process
- The gap between the couple's progressive ideals and their actual behavior
The Unraveling
As secrets emerge and tragedy strikes, Tassie must navigate:
- Family secrets and lies
- The aftermath of 9/11 and America's "War on Terror"
- Her own family's struggles
- The complexities of love, loss, and identity
What Works
The Prose
Moore's writing is exquisite. Her sentences are crafted with precision, often funny, sometimes devastating:
- Sharp observations about human behavior
- Witty commentary on American culture
- Beautiful descriptions of the Midwest
- Clever wordplay and dark humor
The Themes
The book tackles important subjects:
- Transracial adoption and its complexities
- White liberalism and performative progressivism
- Post-9/11 paranoia and Islamophobia
- Coming of age in uncertain times
The Observations
Moore sees through pretense and captures uncomfortable truths about:
- How people perform progressivism
- The commodification of children
- The distance between intention and action
- The way fear changes communities
What Doesn't Work
The Pacing
The novel meanders. While Moore's prose is lovely, the story sometimes feels directionless. Major events happen suddenly, then aren't fully explored.
The Emotional Distance
Tassie observes more than she participates. This creates a remove that can be frustrating - we're watching rather than experiencing.
The Characters
While well-drawn, the characters remain somewhat distant. We understand them intellectually but don't fully connect with them emotionally.
The Structure
The latter half feels rushed compared to the carefully built first half. Some plot developments feel underdeveloped.
Why 3.2 Stars?
This is a case of appreciating a book more than loving it. Moore's writing is undeniably skilled, and the themes are important and thoughtfully explored. The observations about post-9/11 America and white liberalism are sharp and relevant.
However, the emotional distance and uneven pacing kept me from fully connecting with the story. It's a book that made me think but didn't make me feel as deeply as I hoped.
Who Should Read This
- Readers who appreciate literary fiction and precise prose
- Those interested in explorations of race and adoption
- Fans of coming-of-age stories with adult themes
- Readers looking for novels about post-9/11 America
- Anyone who values observation and insight over plot
Final Thoughts
A Gate at the Stairs is an intelligent, well-crafted novel that asks important questions about race, identity, and American culture. Lorrie Moore's prose is beautiful, and her insights are often brilliant.
It's not a perfect book - the pacing is uneven, and the emotional distance can be frustrating. But it's a thoughtful, carefully observed story that lingers in your mind long after you finish it.
If you're looking for beautiful writing and sharp social commentary, this book delivers. If you want a fast-paced, emotionally engaging story, you might find it frustrating. ⭐⭐⭐
My Notes & Takeaways
The Story
A Gate at the Stairs follows Tassie Keltjin, a college student from a rural Midwestern town who takes a job as a nanny for Sarah and Edward, a seemingly progressive couple in Madison, Wisconsin.
The Setting
The novel is set in the months following September 11, 2001, and that atmosphere of fear, uncertainty, and divided loyalties permeates the story. America is at war, and the characters are navigating personal battles against this backdrop.
The Adoption
Tassie becomes part of the family's attempt to adopt a biracial child. Through this process, Moore explores:
- The complexities of transracial adoption
- White saviorism and performative progressivism
- The commodification of Black children
- The gap between good intentions and harmful actions
What Works
Moore's prose is beautiful and observant. She has a gift for precise, devastating observations about human nature. Her sentences are carefully crafted, often funny, sometimes heartbreaking.
The book's exploration of post-9/11 America feels authentic - the paranoia, the sudden divisions, the way fear changes communities.
What Doesn't
The pacing is uneven. The story meanders, and while Moore's writing is lovely, sometimes it feels like we're wandering without clear direction.
The characters, while interesting, remain somewhat distant. Tassie observes more than she participates, which creates an emotional remove that can be frustrating.
Some plot developments feel underdeveloped, particularly in the latter half of the book. Major events happen but aren't fully explored.
Themes
Coming of Age
Tassie is navigating adulthood, trying to understand her place in the world. She's observant but naive, educated but inexperienced.
Race and Identity
The novel unflinchingly examines white liberalism, asking hard questions about adoption, appropriation, and genuine understanding versus performative allyship.
Family Secrets
Everyone in this book is hiding something. The novel explores how secrets shape families and how truth eventually surfaces.
Post-9/11 America
The war, Islamophobia, surveillance, and paranoia form the backdrop of Tassie's personal story.
Final Assessment
This is a book I appreciated more than I loved. Moore's writing is undeniably skillful, and her observations are often brilliant. The themes are important and thoughtfully explored.
However, the emotional distance and uneven pacing kept me from fully connecting with the story. It's a book that made me think more than feel, which may be exactly what Moore intended, but it's not quite what I hoped for.
You Might Also Like
The Cast
by Danielle Steel
Follow the lives of a television ensemble cast over nine years as they navigate fame, relationships, and personal challenges while creating a groundbreaking show.
Girls in Pants: The Third Summer of the Sisterhood
by Ann Brashares
The summer before college - the last summer of innocence, of being together, of the magic pants. Carmen, Tibby, Bridget, and Lena face their biggest transition yet.
The Second Summer of the Sisterhood
by Ann Brashares
The pants are back for a second summer as Carmen, Tibby, Bridget, and Lena face new challenges, deeper heartbreak, and the continued magic of their unbreakable friendship.